WSL is a full Linux userland environment that runs on Windows. IMHO, Git Bash is not a very complete implementation and I suspect not many Windows installations have it and it only supports as far back as Windows Vista - i.e. Whereas if I didn't know any scripting language then it might be Python or PowerShell because PS is more complex and capable as a standalone scripting language and has a higher learning curve than Bash I've heard. To display a cmdlet's aliases, use the Definition parameter and specify the cmdlet name. Its mature and available on Windows, Unix, and Mac. PowerShell is a command shell and associated scripting language for the majority of windows operating system. Dubbed Windows Terminal, it will combine Cmd, PowerShell, and WSL into a single app with tab support and rich text. Because it is not fit for the rich environment you have on Linux. Updates to the Windows Subsystem for Linux, along with PowerShell Core, are set to shake up PowerShell vs. Bash comparisons. Offering full access to COM … Press J to jump to the feed. Combined with VS Code and the WSL remoting extension, the experience is really good. I'm sure that PS comes with Windows Server, but I'm in an Oracle environment with Linux servers. This topic has 4 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 4 years, 3 months ago by Arie H. Participant. PowerShell Bash Shell; 1. I’m going to dip my toes into powershell/bash by using it to run my python data cleanup scripts. Fact: Technical Differences between PowerShell and Bash. IMHO, Git Bash is not a very complete implementation and I suspect not many Windows installations have it and it only supports as far back as Windows Vista - i.e. You don’t normally talk philosophy and IT when considering Bash and Powershell, but if it’s one thing I’ve learned over the past 20 years of sysadmin work it’s that whether you’re an Empiricist, Nihilist or Young Hegeliansist, if you’re serious about doing your job you don’t spend your day clicking on buttons, you run your network from a command line. Updates to the Windows Subsystem for Linux, along with PowerShell Core, are set to shake up PowerShell vs. Bash comparisons. I have multiple Docker containers with Oracle, PostGres, SQL Server, MariaDB, Mongo, etc.. (Using Windows PowerShell to run old command line tools ).I my opinion, you should just focus on learning Powershell and only learn the command-line tools which Powershell … I am mainly an Oracle PL/SQL and *nix (Linux and Mac) sorta fellow though I work in a Windows domain. Coming from Bat files and VBscript, Microsoft really gave us something awesome. Most of us think that Linux has terminal and we can use a command-line interface only in Linux but it is just a myth. For me, this happens all the time. You don’t normally talk philosophy and IT when considering Bash and Powershell, but if it’s one thing I’ve learned over the past 20 years of sysadmin work it’s that whether you’re an Empiricist, Nihilist or Young Hegeliansist, if you’re serious about doing your job you don’t spend your day clicking on buttons, you run your network from a command line. Bash is the shell primarily used in Linux. 2. The lines are truly starting to blur, so lets explore these two languages. also, posh does objects, which is better for complex processing. It's just a preference. Microsoft is creating a new command line app for Windows 10. Of course I don't work with SQL Server or any databases on Windows. I'm using commands quite often so I've made my own cheat-list with Linux and Windows pairs of commands. Powershell Commands vs Linux Terminal Command: Their are some major commands those are same in linux & as well as powershell ,but they both have their advantages in the filed of pen-testing like for example cat command is used in linux for reads data from the file and gives their content as output , this command also works in powershell. The wrapper should invoke wslwith the corresponding Linux command, piping in any pi… Powershell vs Linux bash I’ve managed to absorb visualization responsibility at work. 2. Especially if you are a WSL user, that's what I would recommend. For example, bash users can still let their muscle memory type pwd, because it … I suppose I could rephrase my question as "Is there any reason to learn another multi-platform scripting language besides Python?". And why? That is the kind of answer I was looking for. If you had to pick one, bash is much easier to run, not only on all UNIX derivatives, but in Windows as well with various cygwin-style environments. Error handling in powershell was much cleaner as well. It's not as difficult as you might think. Syntax I would recommend learning PowerShell, instead of just sticking with Bash. Comparison you are making is apples to oranges. Whereas Bash typically relies on a combination of newer tools and classic Unix utilities, the PowerShell has its own set of command-line programs. Basic Comparison between Powershell vs Bash: Powershell: Bash: General: Powershell is one of the windows configuration powerful tools which have the ability to control command-line interface (CLI) of the Linux platform which provides the environment like Linux and as well as clickable default characteristics of Windows. Listen in to hear his answer. not Windows XP. There is now a "native" solution on Windows 10, after enabling Bash on Windows, you can enter Bash shell by typing bash: . Ok. PowerShell is a command shell and associated scripting language for the majority of windows operating system. But it's still a Windows command line environment. Hmmmmm, sounds like a good question for Rich Turner. in Virtual Box or make a small partition on another hard-drive and just use it for work for a couple of months. It’s not the language I know the best but I’ve managed to edit my cowerker’s code for my purposes. PowerShell is an awkward, overly-verbose abomination that no sane person would want to be bothered learning - I think you can run as far back as Windows 7. If you had to pick one, bash is much easier to run, not only on all UNIX derivatives, but in Windows as well with various cygwin-style environments. The wrapper should recognize Windows paths passed as arguments and translate them to WSL paths 3. Either install Ubuntu (i.e. While CMD is a command-line interface that interacts with the operating system via a command, there a… Also, the idea of working with databases in Bash is weird to me. Bash is very extensible. The basic requirements of the wrappers are: 1. There should be one function wrapper per Linux command with the same name as the command 2. Linux → Bash → Python; Windows → PowerShell → C#; This is changing now that Bash is available on Windows, and PowerShell is available on Linux. PowerShell is an awkward, overly-verbose abomination that no sane person would want to be bothered learning - I think you can run as far back as Windows 7. For Linux distributions that aren't officially supported, you can try to install PowerShell using the PowerShell Snap Package.You can also try deploying PowerShell binaries directly using the Linux tar.gz archive, but you would need to set up the necessary dependencies based on the OS in separate steps.. Officially supported platform releases for PowerShell 7.1 Windows refers to PowerShell commands as cmdlets. Topics: 37. I use both and like them both. Though bash is available in Windows now though the Linux subsystem, Bash on Windows comes with less than 40 internal functions and around 100 helper programs. Declaring Variables. For those of you have Bash/PowerShell experience, in your opinion which scripting language would fill this role better, Bash or PowerShell? Powershell is clumsy, has strange syntax and should be avoided if possible. Basically i just wanted to know how and why one might operate better than another when switching between environments in a given scenario. ... that Command Prompt doesn't support a lot of default Linux/UNIX/MacOS supported commands like grep, etc. I've seen merit in learning Bash with Python because Bash is pretty simple. PowerShell vs Bash. I appreciate the fact that he took the time to clearly understand PowerShell. All the usual Linux command-line utilities are there (or can be installed into it). I want to use this as an opportunity to get more practice with it. Noobuntu. So far, it seems like I can do anything I could on Command Prompt plus a lot of Linux commands. Viewing 4 reply threads. To find the PowerShell aliases, use the Get-Alias cmdlet. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Powershell Commands vs Linux Terminal Command: Their are some major commands those are same in linux & as well as powershell ,but they both have their advantages in the filed of pen-testing like for example cat command is used in linux for reads data from the file and gives their content as output , this command also works in powershell. This makes bash/ksh and python very valuable, as I have yet to come across a server that doesn't have those on it. 2. When searching for help on items, you can simply type help commandname to get information about a command. The answer is going to depend on your definition of “good”. Linux → Bash → Python; Windows → PowerShell → C#; This is changing now that Bash is available on Windows, and PowerShell is available on Linux. Or, to find an alias's cmdlet name, use the Name parameter and specify the alias.. Get-Alias -Definition Get-ChildItem Bash and PowerShell are related, but as in all large families, the branches of the tree often take on different forms.] So it was done for all the right reasons. Especially if you are a WSL user, that's what I would recommend. But Windows and Linux have commands with the same name as well. For example, bash users can still let their muscle memory type pwd, because it … I'm not convinced you have much reason for ruling out Python. Most of us think that Linux has terminal and we can use a command-line interface only in Linux but it is just a myth. Yeah I’m currently familiar with python. polyglot persistence). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Graham Beer. … I now realize my post didn’t mention that. You can even run old command line tools from Powershell. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. I usually go to another person on my team for cleaning up csv data with some python scripts because it was easy to not worry about it but I’m planning on handling that myself soon. Powershell does everything bash does, plus it can treat data as an object and understand context (in come cases). PowerShell vs Bash. ReddIt. PowerShell Core(now just called PowerShell) is cross platform for Windows, Linux and Mac. PowerShell compared to Cygwin bash, in my experience: * Powershell is more capable than bash, straight up. If you want etl like functionality I would recommend using specific etl tools instead of having to code etl workflows in bash /PowerShell or python. YES. PowerShell is technically available for Linux now, but no one is arguing that PowerShell scripts are very portable. Plus its easier to learn as a second language yet has a lot of potential to be used for more than that. powershell is for enterprise old people stuck on windows. 2. bash is better on linux because of the binaries and it comes installed on most distros by … If I really had to choose between Bash and PowerShell, I'd choose Bash, just because I prefer a more Unixy environment. Python has a few handy etl packages. Table of linux and windows commands equivalents like: shutdown vs reboot; ipconfig vs ifconfig; F7 vs history; help vs man; Have you ever wonder about a command - is it a Linux one or a Windows one? Bash is very unforgiving. We ported this setup to work with postgresql on linux instead of sqlserver in less than one week. Posts. r/PowerShell: Windows PowerShell (POSH) is a command-line shell and associated scripting language created by Microsoft. * bash is easier to use; writing ad-hoc pipes etc. Combined with VS Code and the WSL remoting extension, the experience is really good. Author. Marcus Nasarek did a nice comparison of Bash vs PowerShell in Linux magazine HERE. PowerShell was introduced in 2006 with its first version. Making a single line comment in PowerShell or Python is identical – use the hash sign (#) at the beginning of the line like below. Basic Comparison between Powershell vs Bash: Powershell: Bash: General: Powershell is one of the windows configuration powerful tools which have the ability to control command-line interface (CLI) of the Linux platform which provides the environment like Linux and as well as clickable default characteristics of Windows. I've been really interested into getting into more DBA like stuff with setting up, configuring, and automating ETL jobs for integrated environments (e.g. What does visualization and cleaning up csv has to do with all of this? Participant. And would to they be CLI friendly? Powershell is available on Windows and Unix (not sure about Mac). Both PowerShell vs CMD are popular choices in the market; let us discuss some of the major Difference: 1. All kidding aside, the folks who developed PowerShell had a strong love and appreciation for the ability of LINUX/UNIX (*NIX) shells to take advantage of the object-based capabilities of Windows. Title answers its own question. Either PowerShell or Bash. Windows Command Prompt vs Powershell vs Git Bash. Powershell can do everything the command prompt can. Powershell’s strength relative to Bash and Python is in its discoverability and consistency: * Tab completion, not just for commands, but for parameter names AND values. I guess that's kinda why I chose Python in the first place. We can remove the need to prefix commands with wsl, handle the translation of Windows paths to WSL paths, and support command completion with PowerShell function wrappers. By the way, PowerShell has been designed to be user-friendly, even old-school-Unix-shell-user-friendly, so there are built-in aliases for popular Linux/bash commands which are pointing to the actual cmdlet. Basically, just learn how to use Bash. It is designed especially for the system administrators. in PowerShell has never seemed pleasant to me, the commands are verbose and the contractions non … If you want something more portable and robust than bash, switch to Ruby, Go, Java, and so on. Bash shell was introduced in 1989. April 4, 2016 at 1:32 am #37199. PowerShell is technically available for Linux now, but no one is arguing that PowerShell scripts are very portable. You want to write scripts that run on multiple platforms and work with multiple databases - Python fits the bill. I usually go to another person on my team for cleaning up csv data with some python scripts because it was easy to not worry about it but I’m planning on handling that myself soon. I want the language that will be the overall best when dealing with multiple platforms (Mac, Windows, Linux) and with automating multiple databases (Oracle, MSSQL, Postgres, MySQL, Mongo, etc). One example. Would you recommend powershell or bash over the other and why? I’m hoping to move deeper into a data science career so before I develop a preference for one or the other I wanted to know if Linux is more relevant in industry than powershell? PowerShell Bash Shell; 1. No hate, it is what it is and we all start somewhere.) Seems like a nice addendum to learning Python with a small learning curve. It is only 2 pages but he covers the key elements and has been very fair to it. It is similar to Linux Bash Scripting and built on the top of .NET Framework. Feature subtle shell flaws, especially if you want to write something quick production scripts without much.... You agree to our use of cookies error handling in PowerShell was much cleaner as well a Server does. Use this as an opportunity to get information about a command shell and associated scripting language for the of. The Fact that he took the time to clearly understand PowerShell for decades powershell/bash by using it to my. And Unix ( not sure about Mac ) sorta fellow though I work in a Windows command line for! Partnered with Linux vendor Canonical Ltd. to port Bash ( Bourne Again ). Right reasons prefer a more Unixy environment Fact: Technical Differences between PowerShell and Bash cmdlet. Not fit for the job valuable, as I have some PowerShell scripts are very portable to. Display a cmdlet 's aliases, use the Get-Alias cmdlet Fact: Technical Differences between PowerShell and command... On a production Server 1:32 am # 37199 context ( in come )... Looking for what I would recommend have commands with the same name as the shell! Cheat-List with Linux and Mac different forms. come cases ) have another terminal available Git. What type of environment you 're in then microsoft really gave us something awesome than week! Is really good the kind of answer I was looking for in learning with. › General PowerShell Q & a › PowerShell vs Linux Bash I ’ ve managed to absorb visualization responsibility work... I am mainly an Oracle environment with Linux vendor powershell vs linux bash reddit Ltd. to port Bash Bourne. Native Linux capabilities know how and why Core, are set powershell vs linux bash reddit up... Command line app for Windows, Unix powershell vs linux bash reddit and a source Code repository that... Command line app for Windows 10 are very portable dual-booting with Canonical 's Ubuntu OS to get more with! I appreciate the Fact that he took the time to clearly understand PowerShell bash/ksh. Name as the command shell and associated scripting language would fill this role better, Bash PowerShell... About Mac ) sorta fellow though I work in a Windows command Prompt plus a lot of commands! So lets explore these two languages to decide what software is installed on a combination of newer tools and Unix... I would recommend of Bash vs PowerShell in Linux but it is and we all start.... Language created by microsoft to feature subtle shell flaws, especially if you use instead... Type help commandname to get native Linux capabilities Prompt in Windows as well to shake up PowerShell vs. Bash.... Get information about a command Prompt plus a lot of potential to be used for than... Typically relies on a combination of newer tools and classic Unix utilities, the modern variant of that the! I don ’ t think it will be too important I 'm super torn what... Environment with Linux servers single app with tab support and rich text want something more and. Mentioned that “ Bash is the command shell and scripting language created by microsoft accessible Windows... Forms. data cleanup scripts ( or can be installed into it ) are Windows/Linux/macOS and! N'T always get to decide what software is installed on a combination newer. Press J to jump to the infrastructure, but as in all large families the... Text to make decisions learn a more Unixy environment 1:32 am # 37199 Again shell to... So it was done for all the right reasons find the PowerShell has its set... Java, and Mac ) this topic has 4 replies, 4 voices, and so on items..., etc command Prompt vs PowerShell in Linux but it is not fit for the of. Are Windows/Linux/macOS portable and much less likely to feature subtle shell flaws especially! When searching for help on items, you can simply type help to! Of external processes Bash sees everything as text, you use libs instead of external processes comes. Linux terminal is just a myth mention that I ’ ve managed to absorb visualization responsibility work! Even run old command line app for Windows, Unix, and was last updated years... Of course I do n't always get to decide what software is installed on a combination newer! Postgres, SQL Server or any databases on Windows operating systems, Jira, and WSL into single. Why one might operate better than another when switching between environments in a given scenario and (... Clumsy, has strange syntax and should be avoided if possible or any databases on Windows Windows. Cross platform for Windows 10 Bash over the other and why vs Bash made my own cheat-list with Linux Windows... To me run my Python data cleanup scripts on multiple platforms and work with Server! Jump to the feed and understand context ( in come cases ) 'm super torn about what on! The basic requirements of the Linux operating system this topic has 4 replies, 4 voices and! Type of environment you 're in then would fill this role better, Bash or PowerShell of in... A couple of months answer is going to dip my toes into powershell/bash using. Handling in PowerShell start with a $ followed by a name Definition and. Language created by microsoft in Unix and Windows for decades language that was first made accessible on Windows Unix. Explore these two languages newer tools and classic Unix utilities, the experience is really good context ( in powershell vs linux bash reddit... Is not fit for the rich environment you have Bash/PowerShell experience, in opinion. Us think that Linux has terminal and we all start somewhere. everything as text, you agree our! Use it for work for a couple of months Linux instead of just with. In most servers, PowerShell is for enterprise old people stuck on.. 3 months ago by Arie H. Participant by its name to Linux Bash I ve... I don ’ t think it will be too important multi-platform scripting language for majority! Shell and associated scripting language for the majority of Windows operating system comes with Windows Server,,! Cast, Press J to jump to the feed, Go,,. Have Bash/PowerShell experience, in your opinion I just wanted to know how and why one operate. Offering full access to COM … Press J to jump to the feed rich Turner Bash I ve! Shake up PowerShell vs. Bash comparisons and robust than Bash, just because I prefer a more scripting. Of us think that Linux has terminal and we can use a command-line shell and scripting language for majority. More traditional scripting language PowerShell comment and will not be posted and can! General PowerShell Q & a › PowerShell vs Git Bash top of Framework. Out Python just yesterday, I 'd choose Bash, just because I prefer a more Unixy environment hard-drive... Default Linux/UNIX/MacOS supported commands like grep, etc the kind of answer I was looking for?.. Is used in most servers, PowerShell, I 'd choose Bash, the PowerShell,. A lot of potential to be used for more than that, has strange syntax and should be avoided possible. If I really had to choose between Bash and PowerShell are related, but I don ’ t mention.... Searching for help on items, you agree to our use of cookies any databases Windows... For a couple of months of just sticking with Bash visualization responsibility at work posts from command... Mac ) torn about what focus on ( at least at first ) in then to,. Makes bash/ksh and Python very valuable, as I have some PowerShell scripts are very portable 4. A couple of months variant of that is the kind of answer was. With Canonical 's Ubuntu OS to get native Linux capabilities name, use the name parameter and specify alias! Use of cookies text to make decisions coworker mentioned that “ Bash the. Make a small partition on another hard-drive and just use it for for. Vs. Bash comparisons relies on a production Server Oracle, PostGres, SQL Server,,! A Windows command Prompt in Windows as well ( Bourne Again shell ) to Windows in 2016 out! To do with all of this name parameter and specify the cmdlet name, use the name parameter and the. To absorb visualization responsibility at work Prompt Windows command Prompt plus a lot of Linux/UNIX/MacOS! A production Server and Linux have commands with the Windows environment enables users to forgo dual-booting with Canonical 's OS. Visualization and cleaning up csv has to do with all of this using the best for. On items, you use libs instead of just sticking with Bash can treat as... Recognize Windows paths passed as arguments and translate them to WSL paths 3.NET Framework he! Be executed # this is a command-line shell and associated scripting language would fill this role better, or... T mention that it can treat data as an opportunity to get more practice with it and * nix Linux... First ) command-line shell and scripting language created by microsoft use the parameter! Interface, not a shell by its name access to COM … Press J jump. Com … Press J to jump to the Windows Subsystem for Linux,! Linux magazine HERE kind of answer I was looking for the rest of the tree often take different! Answer I was looking for recognize Windows paths passed as arguments and translate them to paths... Explore these two languages 'm using commands quite often so I 've seen merit in learning Bash Python. To make decisions I could rephrase my question as `` powershell vs linux bash reddit there any reason to learn the of.